How to Prove You Weren’t at Fault in a Motorcycle Crash

If you’ve been in a motorcycle crash, you’ve probably heard it all already—“Motorcycles are dangerous,” “You must’ve been speeding,” or the worst one: “You were probably at fault.”  In fact, motorcycle crash data from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) reveals that the majority of multi-vehicle motorcycle crashes generally are caused when other drivers simply didn’t see the motorcyclist.

Let’s be clear: you have every right to fight back when another driver’s carelessness causes you serious harm.  Proving you weren’t at fault in a motorcycle accident case can be tough, especially when insurance companies are quick to blame riders. But with the right strategy—and the right attorney—you can establish fault, recover compensation, and protect your reputation.

In this guide, we’ll break down the key steps to prove you weren’t responsible, what pieces of evidence matter most, and how an experienced motorcycle accident lawyer can help you build a solid case.

Why Is Fault So Important in a Motorcycle Accident Claim?

In Washington, your ability to recover damages—like lost wages, medical bills, or pain and suffering—depends on your share of fault.  Therefore, the less responsible you are, the more you can recover.

So if the insurance company is trying to pin the blame on you (even partially), proving fault becomes critical to your recovery.

Step 1: Start With the Police Report

The police report is often the first official document used to establish fault in a motorcycle crash. It may include:

• Diagrams of the scene
• The officer’s observations
• Statements from drivers, passengers, and witnesses
• Traffic citations (like running a red light or reckless driving)

While it’s not the final word, the police report can heavily influence how insurance adjusters view your case.  Because of that, always request a copy as soon as it’s available—and check it for accuracy.

Step 2: Gather Witness Statements

Witness statements can be incredibly powerful in a motorcycle accident case, especially when the other driver tries to twist the truth. A neutral third-party who saw the crash can confirm:

• The other driver’s erratic or distracted driving
• Whether you had the right of way
• That you were riding safely and not speeding or weaving

Get contact info from anyone at the scene, and follow up quickly before memories fade.

Step 3: Secure Video Footage (Dashcams, Traffic Cams, or Nearby Businesses)

Video doesn’t lie—and in a motorcycle crash, video footage can be your best friend.

Here’s where you might find it:

• Dashcams from your own bike or nearby vehicles
• Security cameras from homes or businesses
• Traffic cams at intersections

If you know where the crash happened, act fast. Some footage is erased within days. Your motorcycle accident attorney can help request and preserve this footage as evidence.

Step 4: Document the Scene (Even After the Fact)

If you’re physically able, take photos of:

• The vehicles involved, including damage
• Skid marks, broken glass, or debris
• Road signs, traffic signals, or weather conditions

If you couldn’t take photos at the time, you can still return to the crash site and capture anything that might support your version of events. Your lawyer may also bring in an accident reconstruction expert to analyze the physical evidence.

Step 5: Get Medical Records and Track All Expenses

Your injuries tell a story—especially when the insurance company tries to downplay how serious the crash was.

Be sure to:

• Get immediate medical care
• Follow all treatment plans
• Save every receipt related to your recovery

Your medical records will help link the crash directly to your injuries. They also support your claim for lost wages, physical therapy, and future care.

Step 6: Don’t Talk Too Freely With the Insurance Company

After the crash, the other driver’s insurance company may reach out asking for a statement. They may sound friendly—but make no mistake, they’re looking for anything to use against you.

Common traps include:

• Asking leading questions
• Twisting your words
• Getting you to downplay your injuries

It’s best to direct all communication through your personal injury attorney, especially if liability is disputed.

Common Scenarios Where Fault Gets Disputed in a Motorcycle Crash

Not sure if fault is being wrongly assigned? Here are a few examples of how bikers get blamed—often unfairly:

Left-Turn Accidents

A car turns left in front of a motorcycle going straight. The driver claims they didn’t see the rider, or insists the motorcycle was speeding.

Rear-End Collisions

The driver claims the motorcyclist stopped too fast, when in reality, they were following too closely.

Lane Splitting

Even though lane splitting is illegal in Washington, that doesn’t automatically mean you’re at fault. Each case is fact-specific.

“I Didn’t See Them” Defense

One of the most common excuses drivers give—and one of the weakest. Not seeing a motorcycle doesn’t absolve someone from their duty of care.

In each of these situations, proving you weren’t at fault often comes down to strong evidence and sharp legal representation.

How an Experienced Personal Injury Attorney Can Help

Proving fault in a motorcycle crash isn’t something you should tackle alone—especially when the stakes are high.

An experienced attorney can:

• Investigate the crash thoroughly
• Collect and preserve key pieces of evidence
• Negotiate with the insurance company
• Build a compelling case for compensation
• Represent you in court, if needed

At Abeyta Nelson Injury Law, we’ve represented motorcycle riders throughout Central Washington who’ve been unfairly blamed, underpaid, or ignored. We know how to push back, get the evidence, and tell your side of the story—clearly and powerfully.

What Damages Can You Recover in a Motorcycle Accident Claim?

Once you’ve proven fault, you may be entitled to recover compensation for:

• Emergency medical care and hospital bills
• Ongoing treatment and rehabilitation
• Lost wages and loss of earning capacity
• Pain and suffering
• Damage to your motorcycle and gear

We can help you calculate the full value of your losses—not just what the insurance adjuster is willing to offer.

What If the Other Driver Is Lying?

Unfortunately, it happens. Drivers may lie to avoid blame, especially if they were:

• Texting while driving
• Speeding or driving under the influence
• Running a red light
• Driving without insurance

Don’t panic. Just because someone lies doesn’t mean they’ll get away with it. If you’re facing this situation, our team knows how to investigate, uncover inconsistencies, and bring the truth to light.

Need a Yakima Motorcycle Accident Attorney?

If you’ve been injured in a motorcycle crash and need help proving you weren’t at fault, don’t wait for the insurance company to play fair. Let us step in and do what we do best—protecting your rights and fighting for what you deserve.

Call Abeyta Nelson Injury Law at 509-575-1588, or schedule your free case evaluation today!